36 Comments:

1. Fuck ALW. He did CATS and Phantom of the Opera. He deserves every bad thing that happens to him and his music.

   By thebig28, on April 23, 2008 09:48:30

2. When I heard Webber was going to "mentor" on this week's Idol, I decided right away to pass on the show.

   By catman, on April 23, 2008 10:08:00

3. It's not like ALW's work is particularly good.

   By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 10:15:13

4. Wasn't just her - three of the six singers botched the lyrics at least a little bit.
   
   I like Brooke. But I think she might be toast.

   By Kevin, on April 23, 2008 10:47:11

5. A horrible contribution to classical music.
   Fuck Andrew Lloyd Webber.

   By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 10:54:45

6. All technique, no emotion.
   
   I never watch "American Idol", these clips are about all I get. Good to know I'm not missing much.

   By Hyperbole, on April 23, 2008 11:11:59

7. Brooke has pretty much sucked for many weeks in a row. I think people have given her a chance because of her so-called potential, but she is failing miserably to live up to any potential she has. I, too, initially liked her, but I just can't justify her presence anymore. I think it's time for her to say good-bye tonight.

   By nanster, on April 23, 2008 11:57:32

8. If it's about whose presence can't be "justified," nanster, then Jason Castro (or Juan Epstein, as I like to call him) and David A are the ones who really must go. They're unbearable.

   By catman, on April 23, 2008 12:26:34

9. Brooke is an emotional basket case. She needs to go ASAP, but she is damn good entertainment.

   By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 12:33:31

10. Umm l like Andrew Lloyd Webber. Don't hate on me. (runs in a corner to hide)

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 12:53:58

11. WOW. she sure blew it!

    By SBcouldvedonebettermyself, on April 23, 2008 13:44:41

12. They all pretty much sucked. When that dude sung Memory, I was surprised that real cats didn't jump on stage. The Meow Mix theme would have been better for that stooge.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 13:49:00

13. I was really hoping that she would fuck up after the half of the song, and then ask to start over again to a chorus of boos. Oh well.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 13:49:17

14. Don't watch this crap! Try something good instead, like tonight's Ghost Hunters.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 13:55:48

15. David Cook was actually quite good though.
    
    http://youtube.com/watch?v=4XTXOpVOWrA
    
    

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 14:18:03

16. Jumping the shark. I thought two weeks of horribe Beatle covers was torture enough. What is going on with this show??

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 14:23:43

17. American Idol sucks. Canadian Idol sucks harder.
    
    Dammit, Branson! Build the fucking Time Machine! I wanna go back and strangle the little fucker who thought reality TV would be a good idea!
    
    Slowly. Strangle him slowly. With an ice pick. After having sex with him...of course.
    
    PS: 13:55 is my kind of Anonymous.
    

    By Vigilante, on April 23, 2008 14:47:40

18. I like the British Idol. American Idol sucks monkey balls.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 15:04:33

19. This just in: reality show contestants are dumb.

    By Fred, on April 23, 2008 15:17:42

20. Teh whO?

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 15:41:09

21. David Cook is amazing, I bet he wins American Idol. That is... if all the little female children don't vote the little nostril flaring 17 year old in.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 15:55:43

22. Don't be shocked that ALW's whoring himself out to American Idol... he's done worse. He NEEDS to drum up publicity for that boring-sounding musical of his that's coming out, and his reality show in Canada that will look for the next Maria Von Trapp for the Sound of Music in Toronto. He's hit the nail on the head a few times but mostly he's a tired, pretentious, sexually frustrated codger who averages one sincere, intelligent song per musical, if that.

    By Ling, on April 23, 2008 16:19:33

23. If you want to see good idol, go to you tube and check out clips of Leona Lewis on X Factor (Idol in Britain)...holy crap she is freaking amazing

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 17:51:38

24. If people stop watching than this shit will die.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 17:59:14

25. I'd hit it. No, not Andrew Lloyd Webber -- Brooke!
    
    I bet ALW wore rubber undershorts when he was tutoring David Archuleta so the viewers wouldn't seem him cream his pants.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 18:33:33

26. I agree anonymous 14:18:03. David Cook is the best by far, with Carly in second. Yeah, I know, I shouldn't watch this crap, but I can't help it. Haha.

    By Jessica, on April 23, 2008 18:34:17

27. Say what you want about ALW, but I felt he gave good and honest feedback and actually seemed be mentoring the singers instead of giving non-specific direction like most of the other "mentors".

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 20:08:00

28. I'm mad at myself for watching that entire clip. I was hoping she'd mess up again. Oh well

    By lala, on April 23, 2008 22:01:50

29. I had a pretty strong feeling Brooke would stay. It's weird this year- it's all about the fanbase for each individual instead of how they do each week. I think she stayed because people who like her were afraid she was in trouble and they voted more, and people who might not have voted for her otherwise just felt sorry for her. (As Simon said, she made herself human to the masses)
    And blah blah blah...if you don't like it, don't watch.

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 22:24:38

30. THAT SUCKED ASS why did they got rid of the IRISH chick she was the best last night , the black chick or that UGLY dredlocs geek should had gone ,stupid ass show it sucks

    By anonymous, on April 23, 2008 23:05:03

31. OMG brooke needs to be forced off the show. she always looks like she's about to have a nervous breakdown.

    By anonymous, on April 24, 2008 02:53:04

32. In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is King or in this case, Queen. What a joke. Why don't they choose sides and play tag-team twister to determine a winner?

    By Pony P. Pony, on April 24, 2008 05:19:34

33. nah they should play beer pong

    By anonymous, on April 24, 2008 09:32:38

34. I love andrew lloyd weber, and I wish someone would have sang something from Joesph :(

    By anonymous, on April 24, 2008 11:54:43

35. that's a one twitchy mf, that Lord Andrew... and I just can't believe the blonde mormon chick is even still there - I'm thinking Howard Stern is behind it again

    By gigi, on April 25, 2008 15:07:42

36. It ain't Howard, gigi. It was never Howard's idea to begin with. It's Vote For The Worst.

    By anonymous, on April 26, 2008 15:12:39